Cookie Monster Party Ideas – Cookie Monster Party Supplies

You know Cookie Monster is your favorite from Sesame Street, because COOKIES! These Cookie Monster party ideas will have you grabbing cookies and milk and planning your next party theme!

C is for cookie and P is for party! Today we’re so excited to share a baking and party supply round-up from the shop inspired by one of your very favorite lovable furry monster friends, who happens to be obsessed with COOKIES! (But then again aren’t we all?)That’s right today’s roundup is brought to you by Cookie Monster! So grab yourself a glass of milk and a stack of chocolate chip cookies, it’s time to check out some fun Cookie Monster Party ideas we gathered right here in our shop.

Cookie Dough Frosting Recipe - Cookie Monster Cupcakes on blue background and cookies stacked behind

Cookie Monster Party Cupcakes

Let’s get right to the good stuff today ok? It’s standard just to get right to the sweets right? Maybe that’s just us. Dessert first. Because when you’re looking for Cookie Monster party ideas you’re going to need an awesome cupcake! These cupcakes are super simple to make, and they taste amazing. And when we say amazing we are not kidding. They start with a yellow cupcake baked in our blue dot greaseproof BakeBright cupcake liners. Before the showpiece frosting, we topped with a layer of blue buttercream frosting sprinkled in our very own Cookie Jar sprinkle mix. There’s just something about an extra layer of sweet buttercream dipped in sprinkles! Lastly, we put a scoop of cookie dough frosting. We are not kidding when we say these just might be our favorite cupcake we’ve ever made. Once you top them with two little eyes, they really come to life! They are PERFECT for your upcoming Cookie Monster or Sesame Street party.

Cookie Monster Party Supplies - Cookie Monster Party Ideas collage on blue background

Cookie Monster Party Supplies

While baking cupcakes is always the yummy part of pulling together party ideas at the shop, we have to admit we’re pretty partial to coordinating party and baking supplies as well!  Every single theme makes us just a little bit giddy, and these Cookie Monster party ideas were no exception. These colors are so complementary to each other. We could just see these being used for a Cookie Monster birthday party!

Seeing how a few simple and modern items can pull together to make a fantastic party never gets old. Don’t you get Cookie Monster vibes right away from these items? For this roundup we added our brown BakeBright liners to the mix, as well as our navy blue dot goodie bags to match the blue dot cupcake liners. Then of course we added a Cookie Monster inspired paper party straws.

Cookie Monster Party Ideas - Cookie Monster Party Supplies on blue background

Cookie Monster Party Favors

These goodie bags plus chocolate chip cookies and sprinkles make such a simple party favor. For epic cuteness factor simply add a few edible candy eyes to the chocolate chips just like Cookie Monster! Seriously just how cute are these Cookie Monster cookies?? Talk about a fun, super cute but inexpensive option! We also do a modern feel to character events so adding some solid or patterned notebooks, colors, or other items still keep the cookie monster theme going without being too much. The birthday decorations can be handled the same way.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Frosting Recipe - Cookie Monster Cupcake Idea on blue background and cookies stacked behind

We should probably also mention that when it comes to Cookie Monster party ideas stacks and stacks of chocolate chip cookies make the perfect easy decor! And they double as a snack. Win, win for us! We think they look pretty sweet stacked around our favorite new cookie dough cupcakes. Don’t you think so? Add a chocolate chip cookie pinata and pin the cookie party games and you are good to go! Thanks for following along with our fun Cookie Monster Birthday Party Ideas!


Sprinkles – Cookie Jar

BakeBright Cupcake Liners – Brown, Blue Dot, Blue

Paper Straws – Brown Stripe, Blue Rugby

Goodie Bags – Navy Dot

Reusable Party Spoons – Royal, White

Love these Cookie Monster Party Ideas? Check out these other Party Ideas!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *